Hi. Welcome to the site. Please check out the About Us, and if you have a question about crime and/or punishment, perhaps look at some previous questions along those lines first.
Welcome to Anarchy101 Q&A, where you can ask questions and receive answers about anarchism, from anarchists.

Where does the innovation come from?

0 votes
In an anarchist society where will the innovation come from? In a capitalist society innovation comes with the incentive of money and in an anarchist society there isn't that. Innovation is essentially what has provided us the standard of living today. So where does the incentive to innovate come from in anarchism?
asked Jan 2 by anonymous
interesting tag as "syndicalism", i guess you are referring to the manufacturing of goods?

To me "innovation" is the flowerification/romantization of something very simple that humans do, like you don't think that adding cheese to something you are cooking to enhance the flavor is something that's innovative because people do it all the time. I would guess that anarchists would like innovation to just be innovation again.
a. few anarchists would accept the assumption that we should hold on to our current "standard of living", which comes with a ton of undesirable things (alienation, depression, pollution, systematic injustices, etc etc etc).

b. capitalism =/= competition. further, capitalism limits innovation to certain more or less rigid categories that are understood to be profitable.

c. competition is not the only way to innovate. perhaps some kropotkin is in order?
indeed.

perhaps a working "definition" of innovation would help...

2 Answers

+3 votes

Necessity ?

answered Jan 2 by itsN1X (220 points)
I might add: boredom
+6 votes
"So where does the incentive to innovate come from in anarchism?"

individual desire. anything else would raise questions in my mind about an anarchistic perspective.

i would ask this: why would innovation - much less incentive - be a specific desire/goal of any system that is not economically rooted? wouldn't it be up to each individual to choose in what ways they want to improve their own life (and that of those they care about)?

not saying this is the case, but the question sounds like a typical one asked by @-caps and their brethren.
answered Jan 4 by funkyanarchy (10,190 points)
...