Hi. Welcome to the site. Please check out the About Us, and if you have a question about crime and/or punishment, perhaps look at some previous questions along those lines first.
Welcome to Anarchy101 Q&A, where you can ask questions and receive answers about anarchism, from anarchists.

why do some anarchists say they're anti-anarchism?

+9 votes
they make a big deal about anarchism, i guess instead of saying anarchist ideas? i don't get it.



edited for tags
asked Mar 27, 2010 by anonymous
edited Sep 6, 2014 by dot

2 Answers

+7 votes
The idea is that any set of ideas can get frozen, and become more of a problem than a help.

As an example of this tendency in common language, people talk about "abiding by the letter of the law, instead of the spirit of the law" and here is that same concern that people have stopped paying attention to what is important, and are focusing on the most superficial indicators.
(Another example is in the Bruce Lee movie when he is schooling a student and points to the moon - the student looks at his finger and gets chastised for not looking at the moon in all its heavenly glory.)

People who talk about this usually use the word "ideology" as a problem (ie defining "ideology" as frozen ideas), and refer to anything ending with "ism" as an indication that freezing has happened.
answered Mar 27, 2010 by dot (51,110 points)
+3 votes
Bob Black and others make the distinction of Anarchism vs. Anarchy. Anarchism being a set of theories, whether left-anarchism or anarchism more broadly, whereas anarchy is the lived experience outside of or despite authority.
answered Mar 30, 2010 by enkidu (6,710 points)
...